johnsilver wrote (View Post): |
Polish government officials showed displeasure at Russia over the Ukraine by destroying their WW2 monuments located in Poland.. Looks like Russia is now outraged: |
Quote: |
Now that the Poles are firmly aligned with the West, they are looking forward to all becoming part of the LGBT community and inviting Muslim asylum seekers into Poland by the millions. Meanwhile, David Cameron remains in the closet. |
johnsilver wrote (View Post): |
Wow.. Saying they should have just been more culturally sensitive to every one's point of view? Like.. Instead of tearing down the rusted and crumbling down old monument? Give it a fresh, rainbow colored coat of paint and for good measure? Put up the Hammer & sickle.. Stars & Bars.. Republic Flag of Poland..Anyone who comes along could jab one in the ground so as his/her/it's feelings are not hurt. |
Pzt_Crackwise wrote (View Post): |
Poland has been devastated by the wars it fought against Kingdom of Sweden and Tsardom of Russia back in the 17th century. Since then they have had conflicts with Tsardom of Russia and then Soviet Union almost continuously. |
Pzt_Crackwise wrote (View Post): |
Poland has been devastated by the wars it fought against Kingdom of Sweden and Tsardom of Russia back in the 17th century. Since then they have had conflicts with Tsardom of Russia and then Soviet Union almost continuously. |
Siwy89 wrote (View Post): |
As for Islam and gays- 0,1 % of Poland's inhabitants are muslim, gay marriage is not recognized so I honestly dont know what you are saying Stwa. |
Stwa wrote (View Post): | ||
But all that is going to change. This change is the price Poland must pay its Western Allies. Before long Poland will be just like Holland, except for the high income thing. |
Siwy89 wrote (View Post): |
In nowadays Poland, soviet soldiers (which were "liberating" Poland) are considered as invaders, even worse than Wehrmacht. At first they were cooperating with polish resistance fighters, then when NKWD came, partisans were executed. My grandma told me about soviet's atrocities- they were raping, drunking and stealing all they can get.
Maybe now you can understand why there are soviet's monuments falling in Poland. Polish soldiers that were representing pre-war goverment were fighting with allies in Africa, Italy, France, Holland, Germany. Polish people's army that fought besides soviets was an invention of Stalin only to bring Poland to communist side. This is really complex, but if you are interested I encourage you to read about it. BTW Russian goverment refuses to send us back wreckage of presidential Tupolev (catastrophy in 2010) and yet they have impudence about telling us what to do in our own country. Finally, to be clear I don't want to make some anti russian movement here, I have some friends that are Russians and I like them very much, but ordinary people must be separate from government actions and complex history. As for Islam and gays- 0,1 % of Poland's inhabitants are muslim, gay marriage is not recognized so I honestly dont know what you are saying Stwa. |
kweniston wrote (View Post): |
I thought Dutch anti-Russian propaganda was bad, but the Polish media are really incredible. The Russia of today is being completely mixed up with the Soviet regime, let alone all the other BS concerning the Ukraine.
By rewriting history in this way, the world is being slowly prepared for a WWIII. |
vobbnobb wrote (View Post): |
What did the Nazis get out of invading Poland anyway?? There is nothing there. A strategic location maybe? were any ww2 factories setup there for parts or was it just another "lebensraum" such as France. |
kweniston wrote (View Post): |
This is what my country has come to now: http://rt.com/news/269314-anti-russian-propaganda-netherlands/. |
kweniston wrote (View Post): |
This is what my country has come to now: http://rt.com/news/269314-anti-russian-propaganda-netherlands/. |
Quote: |
I just say look at countries foreign policies to see who the real aggressors are |
sod98 wrote (View Post): |
As for cartoons in schoolbooks: in my country they are intended to engage in subjective discussions about world events. They are not generally used to present off the shelve opinions, which is what the RT article seems to suggest. |
Quote: |
So they aren't intended to tell the truth. Let alone explain the truth to a new generation. I guess that's kweniston was suggesting in his post about Dutch media and you are confirming that. End of the day every good news item is someones opinion backed up with facts and good investigative journalism not scaremongering little kids with propaganda WW2 Nazi Germany style. Sadly ignoring whether it's Dutch, Russian or American propaganda littles very much. Currently the West has embarked upon a campaign of disinformation aimed at countries with differing views, cultures and economies to theirs. Iraq - WMD's, Syria - Sarin gas, Venezuela, Russia, China, Iran and many others. I just say look at countries foreign policies to see who the real aggressors are - 75 countries attacked in individual conflicts by US and many of those by GB and NATO and or UN countries. Don't get me wrong some are warranted but most aren't. |
Siwy89 wrote (View Post): |
I understand your point, but apart from installing goverments US implemented in the West Marshall Plan, Americans were pumping money into western countries (of course mostly for US benefit, obviously). USSR were pumping Marks and Lenin's ideologies into eastern countries so there is the difference. I haven't got friendly altitude towards US politics, just staiting that situation was far worse in the East under Soviets and you can hardly argue about that.
I envy coutries like Switzerland, they manage to be neutral for soooo long. When there was last war in Swiss country? Napoleonic era? Or maybe Spring of Nations period. |
jockthesock wrote (View Post): |
The Germans mainly killed non Germans, the Russians mainly killed Russians. The Russians didn't liberate Poland, they steam rollered over it on their way to Germany, after the Germans put down the Warsaw uprising. |
Siwy89 wrote (View Post): |
I think you are both right about Warsaw Uprising. Russian army was stretched badly and lack of supplies prevents them from taking major actions on Warsaw's front, but this is not the only reason that soviets didn't support rebels. For Stalin it was very convenient that insurgents were fighting with Germans- killing two birds with one stone. Stalin, for most time, forbade american supply planes to land on soviets airfields. Only when uprising was nearly over he allows that. Maybe Americans or Brits could do the same, e.g when suddenly Paris was to be liberated by communists. |
jockthesock wrote (View Post): |
To compare the German occupation with the Russian is not the point. The point is that the Russian system imposed on the Poles could not be described as liberation. As for being embarrassed, I've read Stalin The Red Tsar twice, Leon Trotsky, Stalin and his Hangmen, Lenin, Khrushchev, Eduard Shevardnadze, and Afgantsy. So I am not ignorant of that part of the world. Most westerners would prefer living in post war Greece than post war Eastern Europe, of that I have little doubt.
When asked how the war was won, I have always stated, by Russian blood, American industry and British money. The numbers of Russians who died under Stalin, factless and baseless paranoia, I don't think so. Not a fan of Stephen Ambrose, a bit light weight. |
jockthesock wrote (View Post): |
I'm no fan of Beevor either having read said book. I also haven't ranted. No one writing on Greek classical history have met their subjects either. The material support given to Russia in the earlier days amounted to a huge amount of planes, tanks and especially American trucks, but I have never seen a photo of Russian forces using any of it.
I can understand any Russian feeling aggrieved as to how their role in winning the war was so played down in the west, but the cold war will have to carry some of the blame for that. We in Britain are always moaning that the Americans say they won the war. To my mind the removal of any of the Big Three would have resulted in the loss of the war. As for rape (no one knows or will ever know), complaints being recorded by Police or Hospitals, in Berlin in 1945, seriously! Well this has been an unpleasant chat, which is a shame, as I rarely meet some one who is passionate about history. But your insulting attitude means I shall no longer be responding to your posts. |
output generated using printer-friendly topic mod. All times are GMT