Welcome to Close Combat Series
  Login or Register Home  ·  Downloads  ·  Forums  ·  Combat Camera  ·  Help  

  Survey
Do incapacitations count as a soldier's kills?

Yes
No



Results
Polls

Votes 1261
Comments: 1

  Shout Box!!

Only registered users can shout. Please login or create an account.

  Main Menu
Articles & News  
    Help
    Player`s News
    Site News
    Multiplayer
    Terrain Challenge
    Boot Camp
Community  
    Forums
    Downloads
    Combat Camera
    MOOXE @ Youtube
    Statistics
Members  
    Private Messages
    Your Account
    Logout

  Donations
Anonymous - $25.00
08/15/2022

Anonymous - $25.00
08/15/2022

Anonymous - $25.00
12/18/2021

Anonymous - $100.00
11/08/2021

Anonymous - $15.00
04/09/2021

Anonymous - $100.00
04/05/2021

Anonymous - $20.00
02/20/2021

Anonymous - $10.00
12/29/2020

Anonymous - $1.00
11/06/2020

ZAPPI4 - $20.00
10/10/2020

Find our site useful? Make a small donation to show your support.



Search for at
Close Combat Series Advanced Search

Search found 17 matches
Close Combat Series Forum Index
 
 
Author Message
  Topic: Highest Scoring Panzer Ace, tank type within grand campaign?
cronus

Replies: 12
Views: 12623

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Fri Mar 24, 2006 7:25 pm   Subject: Highest Scoring Panzer Ace, tank type within grand campaign?
PzKpfw IVG

Leader Setz
Gunner Dreier
Loader Busch
Assistant Lobewein

9 tank
24 infantry

Still alive in central sector chasing after the T34s Very Happy
  Topic: Highest Scoring Panzer Ace, tank type within grand campaign?
cronus

Replies: 12
Views: 12623

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 11:52 am   Subject: Highest Scoring Panzer Ace, tank type within grand campaign?
I would like to learn the best panzer ace from German and Russian side within the Stalingrad great campaign mode in H2H or against computer action.

Please write down the tank type, scores of the tank and name of the tank commander, come on. Very Happy
  Topic: Open topped Marder II and such vehicles..
cronus

Replies: 10
Views: 9982

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Fri Mar 17, 2006 8:42 am   Subject: Open topped Marder II and such vehicles..
I don't think that the Marders are not potent weapons. With experienced crew and with good ambush conditions, they can be deadly weapons. I have a MarderII within a panzer battlegroup which knocked' out 2 KV1s..

I think small arms fire should not be able to penetrate the front armour of MarderII.
  Topic: Who's getting their butts whooped?
cronus

Replies: 15
Views: 13008

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Fri Mar 17, 2006 7:30 am   Subject: Finishing off the KV1 Battlegroup
I've been fighting with the KV1 battlegroup for three turns, all the map locations around it belongs to me and finally it's lack of fuel and KV1s can not move now.

My panzer battlegroup is only with 2 MarderIIs, 1 PanzerIIIs, 1 Sdkfz 232 and without any AT gun. I've lost all PzIV's and PzIII's with stable fire actions against KV1's. But it's completely useless.

At the last battle I've finished off 3 KV1's with MarderIIs and PanzerIII by fighting them with a very mobile attack, stop-fire-move action. KV1's can not even aim their gun in time to respond me.

I'm going to finish of that monsters.
  Topic: Open topped Marder II and such vehicles..
cronus

Replies: 10
Views: 9982

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 8:19 am   Subject: Open topped Marder II and such vehicles..
On an occasion last night in stadium map, I was leading an assult on a russian stronghold with two groups of panzergrenadiers and a MarderII for heavy fire support on the building. But I was very surprized when the things go wrong...

I've had supressing fire from the building at about 150meters. Instantly repulsed the fire with my one infantry group but I found that all the Marder crew is dead!

Fire was coming from the front and not above, I'm sure that they didn't use rifle bomb or antitank gun or tank rifle, crew died from the regular rifle fire.

With an armour plating front, how did it happen?
  Topic: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
cronus

Replies: 46
Views: 28314

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2005 7:51 am   Subject: PzIIIL still outperforms PZIVG
Stupid thing is that the direct hit ratio of the PZIVG is far worse than the T34 or PzIIIL.

PZIIIL>T34>PzIVG.

Is there anything in the game data that simulates the aiming capability of the gun systems of these tanks?

One thing is for sure: PzIVG is not a capable tank in this mode even with veteran crew. Such a waste of valuable resources.
  Topic: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
cronus

Replies: 46
Views: 28314

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Mon Dec 05, 2005 7:37 am   Subject: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
About the patch 1.2.

After the installation of the patch, I've had a fight with Russian armour group in south stalingrad dock. I don't know the port name but with couple of ships.

I've had 3 PzIIIJs, 2 PzIVGs, 2 PzIIFs, 1PzIVF.
Russian armour group had 2 T70s, 4 T34s.

At the start, I've positioned my 2 PzIVGs on longe range duel positions and PzIIIJs in ambush positions.

After the initial long range(230-240m) fire duel with PZIVGs and T34s, 2 T70s destroyed, one T34 incapacitated, and a T34 is damaged. My 2 PzIVGs are destroyed.

Seems a better long range AT capacity. It seems panzers need longer ranges to overcome the losses.
  Topic: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
cronus

Replies: 46
Views: 28314

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2005 7:48 am   Subject: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
Hehe, 20 mm T60 gun is pretty usefull Ithink. I have one captured unit still in operation at the 5th day and tank commander got many decorations including the iron cross..Has three tanks, a field gun and over 30 infantry killings. It's fast, small (hard target) and pretty good gun for short engagements, I wonder if it can see the end of the campaign Question

Dima, do I have to wait for the next patch for the PzIVG L/43 gun correction? Cause I don't know the data editing.
  Topic: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
cronus

Replies: 46
Views: 28314

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Sat Nov 26, 2005 12:37 pm   Subject: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
No it was a T60, it ended up my PZIVG from the back. It was 60-70 meters away from Pz and Pz couldn't rotate the gun in time.

How can we correct the PzIVG gun issue?
  Topic: Single barrel supply depot. Worthless in Stalingrad mod?
cronus

Replies: 16
Views: 10272

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Fri Nov 25, 2005 1:05 pm   Subject: Single barrel supply depot. Worthless in Stalingrad mod?
Maybe the reason is all the adjacent areas are German territory.(As far as I can see)
  Topic: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
cronus

Replies: 46
Views: 28314

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Fri Nov 25, 2005 9:01 am   Subject: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
Actually I copied the data from a file, so editing was not a big problem Laughing

Personally I don't rely on PZIVG's to engage the enemy armour. They may have a better gun in real life but, it does not show itself in gameplay I don't know why? I hope you can find. Maybe an easy data correction can save the situation.

As your examples in most conditions a T-34 knocks out the PzIVG even it takes the first hit. I've never seen an occasion that the PzIVG knocked out a hard target at the first hit, maybe there is an accuracy problem for the gun.

I've lost a PZIVG against a T-60, at a h2h fight. Pz fired maybe 6 times, T-60 fired 3-4 rounds and immobilized my unit. Dissapeared and then moved back of my unit and knock'ed it out by a back shot from 70 meters. Then I could kill the T-60 with a PzIID!!!

This gives germans a big disadvantage and hinters the gameplay so much I think, because limited numbers of German panzer groups are heavily based on PzIVG medium tanks. And they are not reliable units that you can base a strategy on them. They are generally useless against enemy armour.

I can not see so much difference between assulting on a position possibly guarded by enemy tanks with or without PZIVGs. Because they turn to burning wrecks immediately.
  Topic: German Anti-tank teams
cronus

Replies: 27
Views: 31293

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Thu Nov 24, 2005 9:40 am   Subject: PzBuchse 39
My PzBuchse 39 team killed two T34 last night, one shot is 9 meters away, the other is 23 meters away, two of the shots were side shots. Team was ambushed in first floor of a roofles building.

I think this unit is an excellent tank killer when it's used in city at close range.
  Topic: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
cronus

Replies: 46
Views: 28314

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Thu Nov 24, 2005 8:18 am   Subject: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
Dima wrote:
Argon,

study topic better bfr making such conclusions...
Quote:
Yes that's fine n' all, but as I read the T-34 could penetrate 60 mm from 1Km with the standard APHE shell and Pz III had 50 mm in the front

60mm vs what kind of armor plate? which PzIII had 50mm frontal armor? What type of armor PzIII had?

Quote:
There are dumb situations where Mk IVH kicks the living sh** out of IS-2

so what? why PzIVH couldn't pen. JS-2? I'd say at ranges closer than 500m JS-2 had no chances vs PzIVH(only if JS hit PzIVH at first shot).

1) PzIII was always better armored than PzIV as it was supposed to fight vs tanx(by german doctrine) and PzIV was for inf support role.
2)5cm KwK39 PzGren40 (APCR) could pen 151mm@100m/90deg(147mm@100m/90deg for KwK40(APCR)) but lacked AP power at further ranges 84mm@500m/90deg (KwK40=126mm@500m/90deg). So at ranges up to 200-300m KwK39/Pak38 can KO anything.

Each german tank have 8 SP(APCR) shells in Stal.

Quote:
it is easier to kill any T-34 with the PzIIIJ than with the PzIVG in Stalingrad mod

yes at ranges up to 200-300m. As it has better AP perfomance and better ROF.

Quote:
Point is this. Why the small caliber L60 is better than 75mm long barreled L48

there is no 7.5cm L/48 in Stal mod at all.


Yes, I've made a mistake to think that the PzIVG's with L48 gun. But the early variants had L43 gun, which is comparable to Soviet F34 gun and L48 gun,so there is no big difference between them.

75mm KwK 40 L/43
Penetration of Armor Plate at 30 degrees from Vertical.
Ammunition:.......100m 500m 1000m 1500m 2000m
Panzergranate 39 98mm 91mm 82mm 72mm 63mm
Panzergranate 40 126mm 108mm 87mm 69mm 0mm

Pzgr.39 (APCBC) - Armor Piercing Composite Ballistic Cap
Pzgr.40 (APCR) - Armor Piercing Composite Rigid (Tungsten Core)

50mm KwK 39 L/60
Penetration of Armor Plate at 30 degrees from Vertical.
Ammunition:.......100m 500m 1000m 1500m 2000m
Panzergranate 39 67mm 57mm 44mm 34mm 26mm
Panzergranate 40 130mm 72mm 38mm 0mm 0mm

But there is a BIG difference on the paper with the L/43 and L/60 guns,in favor of PzIVG's L/43 gun. But the Stalingrad mod experince tells the opposite. I've seen many occasions that the L/60 gun is far better at penetrating of T34's and KV-1's armour.

Let's come to the armour issue;

The armor of PZIIIJ/L/M;
Front Turret: 57/15
Front Upper Hull: 50+20/9
Front Lower Hull: 50/21
Side Turret: 30/25
Side Upper Hull: 30/0
Side Lower Hull: 30/0
Rear Turret: 30/12
Rear Upper Hull: 50/17
Rear Lower Hull: 50/9
Turret Top / Bottom: 10/83
Upper Hull Top / Bottom: 18/79
Lower Hull Top / Bottom: 16/90
Gun Mantlet: 50+20/0

The armor of PzIVG;
Front Turret: 50/11
Front Upper Hull: 50 or 50+30/10
Front Lower Hull: 50 or 50+30/12
Side Turret: 30/26
Side Upper Hull: 30/0
Side Lower Hull: 30/0
Rear Turret: 30/10
Rear Upper Hull: 20/12
Rear Lower Hull: 20/9
Turret Top / Bottom: 10/83
Upper Hull Top / Bottom: 12/85
Lower Hull Top / Bottom: 10/90
Gun Mantlet: 50/0

PzIIIJ/L/M's armour is slightly better than PzIVG, but I think it does not give an edge for PzIII to fight against enemy tanks over PZIVG.
  Topic: In an occasion
cronus

Replies: 2
Views: 2849

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Tue Nov 22, 2005 11:59 am   Subject: In an occasion
There is some map which connects to three other maps to east. I don't remember the name, will take a picture shot. In that case, you cannot do anything to cover your back.
  Topic: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
cronus

Replies: 46
Views: 28314

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Tue Nov 22, 2005 10:07 am   Subject: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
They were battle hardened T34 obr.42s...Not the rookie ones, they reacted pretty well but I was luckier and faster.

Point is this. Why the small caliber L60 is better than 75mm long barreled L48?? This is not one occasion, I've been experiencing this all the time.

When your PzIVG fires a AP on a T34, it almost always immobilize or damage it but not kill it. But when an experienced PZIII crew fires on T34 from even distances like 500m, it almost always kills it at the first shot, if not, PzIIIJs fast reloading time is the reason of a death T34.

I have a PzIIIJ with 8 hard target credits, two of them are KV1s. Never a PzIVG could achieve that score.
  Topic: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
cronus

Replies: 46
Views: 28314

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:31 pm   Subject: MarkIIIL vs T34...Three blown T34s in a raw..
I've been experiencing that the small caliber 50mm L60 gun of the PzIII is better than the PZIVG's 75mm L48 gun against hard targets like T34 and KV1.

Last night my microcontrolled PzIII knocked out 3 t34s in a raw less than a minute. I came out of the forest and first 2 of the shots are sideshots and the last one is on the front..I achieved this with run-stop-fire. At the edge of the forest I did the first shot, they were unaware of me..first T34 knocked out..All 2 T34s fired at me but I was on the move, they missed. When they were reloading, I stopped and fired, second one blown.Then moved again, the last one turned on me with the hull, fired again and missed, then I stop and fired, it was a direct hit from the front.. 3 shots, 3 success, it was quiet a view.I could never do it with a PzIVG, cause it's slower and somewhat it's aim is worse even with experienced crew.
  Topic: Strategic Map Movements
cronus

Replies: 2
Views: 2909

PostForum: CC5 Stalingrad   Posted: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:15 pm   Subject: Strategic Map Movements
After the first three days of fight, I kicked off the first line of Russian defence forces.Then I moved my forces forward and when after the execution of movements I've seen that the areas left behind are again Russian!!!Because some Russian movement has been done...

So what will happen afterwards?? Some positions have 2 or 3 possible movements and when you move your force forward, he moves his forces to the place that you left behind. In this manner, you will not be able to get the new forces and replacements..And you are out of ammo and oil..

What should I do for this?
 
 
 
Page 1 of 1
Time synchronized with your computer time
Jump to:  




Forums ©





In August of 2004, Zappi, Homba, Bambam887, RedScorpion and MOOXE all pitched
in to create this Close Combat site. I would to thank all the people who have visited and
found this site to thier liking. I hope you had time to check out some of the great Close Combat
mods and our forums. I'd also like to thank all the members of our volunteer staff that have
helped over the years, and all our users that contributed to this site!