Still didn't see answer to my question why do you prefer Autocratic-Dictatorship rule vs Liberal Democracies of EU?
My preferences are off-topic. I don't hide my sympathies for Russia and here I give my opinion on what I think Russia should do to win this war.
For the Russian national interest:
Good -> independent countries integrated in EAEU & CSTO, like Belarus or Kazakhstan
Bad -> independent countries trying to be members of EU and NATO, like Ukraine or Georgia.
Yes I respect your opinions, thus why the question. I don't believe it to be off-topic? Let me ask the question in a different way then...
To your additional point, why is it "bad" for nations to want to join European Union or NATO...and "good" to Russian syndicate state?
It's basically the same question why Autocratic state is "good" and EU liberal state is "bad".
I consider that a multipolar world with a balance between powers is better than a unipolar and I consider that EU is simply a tool for German and French Big Businesses that destroyed my country's industry and converted it into a giant resort (and no country can become a power only by exporting agricultural products or attracting tourists).
Because this territory is Russia (Malorussia - Little Russia, original Russia). It's like ancient Greece (as Ukraine is now) in Greece and Magna Graecia (now Russia) in Southern Italy. I'm sure you understand this historical example. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Graecia ...and, because the dollar is not yet sufficiently reduced as a world reserve currency https://asiatimes.com/2022/10/the-world-at-a-turning-point/
Because this territory is Russia (Malorussia - Little Russia, original Russia). It's like ancient Greece (as Ukraine is now) in Greece and Magna Graecia (now Russia) in Southern Italy. I'm sure you understand this historical example. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Graecia ...and, because the dollar is not yet sufficiently reduced as a world reserve currency https://asiatimes.com/2022/10/the-world-at-a-turning-point/
Why did Russia wait 30 years to change it's mind that Ukraine should not be sovereign nation as all parties agreed to when the Soviet Union ended? You are making a big assumption that Ukraine wants to be re-united with old Soviet style rulers. Ukraine has made this quite clear for 100 years they do not.
When America wanted its independence from Imperial Britain, we also had to fight for it against all odds and virtually zero navy. It was not even like what Ukraine and Russia negotiated to respect each other as separate sovereign nations and peaceful transition of power. Then similar to Russia, England later changed its mind and invaded, burned down our capital and wanted revenge. And again Imperial Britain mis-calculated, it was far too late. Once Free people have the freedom, land and sovereign rule...we never want to revert back to Autocracy and rule by force. We will fight you and will never stop to until you go back home to your country. Imperial Britain learned this, Russia will also.
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2022 1:35 pm Post subject: Re: War in Ukraine?
Quote:
When America wanted its independence from Imperial Britain, we also had to fight for it against all odds and virtually zero navy.
One side of truth. Other side is about that-time NATO incendiarism and direct support, with France using americans as secondary front in their war with Britain, fueling with weapons, volunteers, providing navy support, and Spain made a land operation against Britain in Florida and naval operations in Caribbean, and Dutch also took their part. Otherwise Washington and others would be not so dare for open depart from crown.
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2022 7:34 pm Post subject: Re: War in Ukraine?
In retaliation for the drone attack against Sebastopol naval base, Russia broke the exporting grain deal.
Well, if I were the president of Argentina or Brazil, I would take the opportunity to sell grain to Egypt and other African countries that depended on Ukrainian exports.
Quote:
When America wanted its independence from Imperial Britain, we also had to fight for it against all odds and virtually zero navy.
I consider that a multipolar world with a balance between powers is better than a unipolar and I consider that EU is simply a tool for German and French Big Businesses that destroyed my country's industry and converted it into a giant resort (and no country can become a power only by exporting agricultural products or attracting tourists).
So there's my 2 reasons to support Russia.
I will say, that I these views are not accurate in terms of the goals of multi-national coalitions or even why they exist. The United Nations, which Russia belongs to is one such multinational organizations. Doesn't always stop wars but it is effective for nations to denounce aggression, confront war crimes and creating consensus of many nations. The EU likewise was formed to help simplify trade within member nations, promote Unity of member nations and reduce conflicts. I dispute the perception that Nations lose their National identity or sell-out belonging to multi-national coalitions such as the UN or EU.
As far as the negative experience you suffered by German/French corporations...that is different situation in my opinion. We as global citizens are indoctrinated to believe that "free trade" , capitalism and corporations are good and we should not regulate their interests. Corporations sole purpose is to ruthlessly make as much profit for themselves at all times. Even if illegal or if their actions damage environment or destroys economies of local communities. In fact, many companies know they are violating sanctions / laws / or cause suffering and would rather pay criminal Fines if less expensive vs doing the right thing.
Also I dispute the common perception that Autocracies are "strong" and Liberal democracies are "weak". Many right wing ideologies glorify Autocracy or aspiring Dictators as tough or strong so I understand your point of view. It's all theatrics. In reality Communist China & North Korea, Iranian Islamic Dictatorship or Putin's Fascist Police State are all weak and scared of Liberal Democracies. Why? Because Freedom, Independent Media, the right to question your State or demand transparency poses clear and present danger to Authoritarian rule.
- Ukraine already consumed 35 Bil USD of 'help'
- Ukraine will cost for West around 5 Bil USD/month just to keep in place
- Ukraine have absolutely no prospects of earn that money by itself in foreseeable future = irredeemable debt for centuries
- All the hopes are on Russia's sudden give up.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You cannot attach files in this forum You can download files in this forum
In August of 2004, Zappi, Homba, Bambam887, RedScorpion and MOOXE all pitched
in to create this Close Combat site. I would to thank all the people who have visited
and found this site to thier liking. I hope you had time to check out some
of the great Close Combat mods and our forums. I'd also like to thank
all the members of our volunteer staff that have helped over
the years, and all our users that contributed to this site!